The Unregulated Ten: Chlorinated Ethanes and Propanes in Your Water

When you look at the results of a comprehensive drinking water test, it can feel like you’re reading a foreign language. There’s a long list of chemical names, and usually, there are columns next to them. One column says “Result,” another says “MCL,” which stands for Maximum Contaminant Level—the legal limit set by the federal government—and maybe another column for “MCLG,” the health goal. For most people, if they see a “ND” for Non-Detect or a number below the MCL, they breathe a sigh of relief.

But what happens when you see a chemical name, maybe even a positive detection number next to it, and the columns for the federal limits and health goals are completely blank? That is the quiet, unsettling reality for a specific family of industrial chemicals I’ve seen pop up on lab reports for years. These are the “Unregulated Ten.”

These ten chemicals are a subset of a broader class called Volatile Organic Compounds, or VOCs. In plain English, they are man-made chemicals that evaporate easily and dissolve in water. This family includes several chlorinated ethanes, some propanes, and one specific trichlorobenzene. These are industrial-age solvent chemicals, born of a time when the focus was on manufacturing and degreasing, with little understanding of where these compounds would end up.

The single most important headline fact you need to know about all ten of them is this: not one of these ten chemicals has a federal drinking-water limit.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has never set an MCL, which is the enforceable legal limit. They have also never set an MCLG, which is the non-enforceable health goal. When you look at the massive federal database of water quality or hold that certified lab report in your hand, these chemicals are there. They are detected during testing, they are listed, but they are left completely unregulated at the federal level. There is no line in the sand drawn by Washington for any of them.

The Ten Names on the List

Let’s take a look at these chemicals one by one. Understanding what they are and what they were used for helps paint a picture of why they are moving through the groundwater.

1,1,1,2-Tetrachloroethane: This chemical is a chlorinated solvent and what’s called a “chemical intermediate.” In the practical world, its main job, particularly during the 1990s, was as a building block—a feedstock—for making two very well-known and regulated solvents: trichloroethylene (TCE) and tetrachloroethylene (PCE). While its commercial production in the U.S. has ceased, its past use means it can still be present in the environmental legacy.

1,1,2,2-Tetrachloroethane: This compound is a manufactured solvent that was once used in large, significant amounts to make other chemicals, as well as to clean and degrease metal. While its historical footprint is large, today it is only used as a chemical intermediate. It’s an “ancestor” molecule that you often find in groundwater, having survived from that era of heavy use.

1,1-Dichloroethane: This solvent has a dual identity. It was used mostly to manufacture another common chemical, 1,1,1-trichloroethane. It was also used as an intermediate in vinyl chloride production and, on a smaller scale, as a solvent and degreaser. Crucially, 1,1-dichloroethane also forms in the environment. When its “parent” chemical, 1,1,1-trichloroethane, breaks down in the ground, this is one of the breakdown products that is left behind.

1,1-Dichloropropene: This name is on the list, and it shows up in lab scans, yet it is profoundly obscure. When the federal National Toxicology Program conducted a thorough review of this chemical, they found no documented information at all on what it is actually used for. This is a common situation with the unregulated ten: they exist, they are in the water, but they are data-poor.

1,3-Dichloropropane: This is another chemical used in the manufacturing of other chemical compounds, including cyclopropane production. While it sounds similar to some common pesticides, 1,3-dichloropropane has never been a registered pesticide in the United States. It can appear in water as a trace contaminant, making up less than 0.1% of Telone fumigant products.

1,3-Dichloropropene: This one deserves the fullest explanation because it is the “headline” name of the propane group. It is the core component of the Telone soil fumigant, a preplant nematicide. A nematicide kills nematodes, which are parasitic worms in the soil that destroy crops. This chemical is still very widely used in agriculture today. What you buy as commercial Telone is actually a mixture of two slightly different forms of the molecule. This leads us directly to the next two names on your test report.

cis-1,3-Dichloropropene and trans-1,3-Dichloropropene: These are the two geometric isomers that make up commercial Telone. Think of isomers as two shapes of the same molecule. They have the same chemical formula, but their shape is different, which can affect their properties slightly. This is where lab reports can get confusing for a homeowner. While you might know a product by one name, the laboratory has to analyze for the specific shapes. For example, California monitors them as two separate test analytes on a lab sheet, but when it comes to regulation, they are added together and regulated under the single 1,3-dichloropropene limit. This explains why one product, Telone, might become three lines on your water report—the cis form, the trans form, and the total.

2,2-Dichloropropane: This is used in production as part of creating isomerization catalysts, which are crucial for the petroleum industry. But like 1,1-dichloropropene, this chemical is another data-poor name from that same federal review. We know it’s used in industry, we find it in water, but the publicly available data on it is minimal.

1,2,3-Trichlorobenzene: This chemical is a solvent and a chemical intermediate used in pesticide, pigment, and dye production. Trichlorobenzenes have historically served other niche roles, such as dielectric and heat-transfer fluids. However, 1,2,3-trichlorobenzene is produced in smaller amounts and has been studied far less than its “cousin,” 1,2,4-trichlorobenzene. Do not confuse the two. This is critical. Why? Because 1,2,4-trichlorobenzene is federally regulated. The 1,2,3- form is not.

The Numbers That Do Exist: A State-by-State Patchwork

Now that you know the names, let’s go back to the central problem. The EPA in Washington has not set any standards. This silence has created a problem for states that know these chemicals are in their residents’ groundwater. To address this, some states have stepped in to set their own rules. This has resulted in a patchwork of regulations where your protection depends entirely on where you happen to live.

This is a good time for a brief data definition. You will often see numbers listed as µg/L, which means micrograms per liter. This is exactly the same concentration as ppb, or parts per billion. I use µg/L here because that’s how the regulations are often written. To wrap your head around that, imagine one grain of sand in a massive, sand-filled room; that grain of sand is your part per billion.

Let’s look at the patchwork of numbers that some states have created for a few of these chemicals.

For 1,1-dichloroethane, California has set an enforceable MCL, a legal limit, of 5 µg/L. New Jersey, looking at the same science, has set an enforceable MCL of 50 µg/L. That is a ten-fold difference. New Jersey allows fifty parts per billion; California allows only five. For chemicals that are unregulated at the federal level, your safety is literally dependent on which state line your well happens to be on. No other state drinking-water limit was found in my review of the data for this chemical.

For 1,3-dichloropropene (the Telone fumigant), California has set a very tight MCL of 0.5 µg/L. To put that into perspective, the World Health Organization’s (WHO) non-enforceable drinking-water guideline for 1,3-dichloropropene is 20 µg/L—forty times higher than California’s enforceable legal limit. Again, there is a lack of consensus on what a safe number should be, so the numbers vary wildly depending on who is doing the counting.

For 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane, both California and New Jersey have set an identical enforceable MCL of 1 µg/L.

It’s also important to note that state agencies sometimes publish what they call non-enforceable Public Health Goals. These are goals, not legal limits. For the same three chemicals just discussed, California publishes goals of 3 µg/L for 1,1-dichloroethane, 0.2 µg/L for 1,3-dichloropropene, and a very low 0.1 µg/L for 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane. For the other seven names on our list, I found no specific state drinking-water limit in California or New Jersey. For those seven, there is no number at all.

Health Framing: What the Classifications Mean

The reason states and international organizations are debating these numbers and, in some cases, not setting numbers at all, is that the human data on these compounds is often limited. To evaluate risk, scientists and regulatory bodies use classification systems based on available studies. This gets complicated, so let’s translate what these classifications actually mean in plain English.

IARC is the International Agency for Research on Cancer. They use a number of groups to categorize their findings. One you will see applied to some of these chemicals is “Group 2B.” This is defined as being “possibly carcinogenic to humans.” When you read that, it means the evidence for cancer in humans is limited or nonexistent, but there is sufficient evidence that the chemical causes cancer in lab animals. It’s a category that says, “We have strong warnings from animal studies, and the human question is not yet settled.”

Here is how the main agencies have classified some of our “Unregulated Ten”:

Both tetrachloroethanes (1,1,1,2- and 1,1,2,2-) are classified by IARC as Group 2B, possibly carcinogenic to humans. This is based specifically on the evidence found in animal studies. Both of these chemicals are also listed as carcinogens under California’s well-known Proposition 65.

1,1-Dichloroethane is also listed as a Proposition 65 carcinogen and is classified by the EPA itself as a Group C, “possible human carcinogen.” This means that while the human data is weak, the agency sees enough evidence in some studies, often in animals, to trigger a “possible” flag.

1,3-Dichloropropene is a Proposition 65 carcinogen and is in IARC’s Group 2B again. However, the EPA’s classification here is stronger; the EPA lists it as a “probable human carcinogen” based on extensive rodent studies.

For the data-poor names on our list—1,1-dichloropropene, 1,3-dichloropropane, 2,2-dichloropropane, and 1,2,3-trichlorobenzene—the honest finding, based on federal reviews, is simply how little human data exists at all. These are chemical compounds that are found in water, but we lack the foundational human data needed to place them in any of these risk categories. Their health data, like their regulation, remains a gap in the record.

What Removes Them: Physical Answers for a Chemical Family

This is always the real-world question: “It’s on my test report. Now how do I get it out?”

Since these ten compounds are all part of the Volatile Organic Compound family, we rely on their physical characteristics for removal. Because they are volatile, which means they want to evaporate out of water readily, aeration is one answer. Also known as “air stripping,” this process literally blows air through the water, causing the chemical to migrate from the water phase into the air phase and then get vented away.

The other primary answer, and the most common application for homeowners, is granular activated carbon. This material does not “filter” like a fine-mesh screen; instead, it works by a process called adsorption. The chemical compounds are literally attracted to the massive internal surface area of the carbon, and they stick to it as the water passes through.

I must state plainly that carbon performance varies significantly by specific compound. While these chemicals are in the same general family, their specific structure matters. No honest water professional would ever give a per-chemical removal guarantee for compounds that nobody regulates. We can apply the best, proven physical solutions for the VOC class as a whole, but we cannot predict the precise performance on each individual unregulated chemical.

The Bottom Line

When it all shakes out, here is Steve’s verdict on the “Unregulated Ten.” Ten chemical names appearing on a lab report with no federal number beside them is not, by itself, proof of an immediate, acute danger. But it is also not, in any way, proof of safety. It is a gap. It is a space in the information where the federal government has not spoken.

The fact that states like California and New Jersey have felt compelled to step into that gap and set their own numbers—numbers that differ significantly between them—simply shows how wide that gap is. It highlights the uncertainty. It means that what one state considers a safe limit, another state might view as a serious concern. If you see these chemicals on your water test, don’t look for reassurance where none exists. Acknowledge that you are looking at compounds whose regulation is unsettled, and use that information as the starting point for deciding how you want to manage your home’s water.

Facts first, then filter. — Steve

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *