When a laboratory water test reaches down into the obscure tail of the contaminant list, two names occasionally turn up that stop homeowners in their tracks: dimethyl sulfide and ethanethiol. After a lifetime in professional water treatment, now spent teaching homeowners how to make sense of their own reports without getting rattled by chemical jargon, I always tell people that these two belong in a category all their own—not because of what they do to a test tube, but because of what they do to the human nose.
The Family
Both names carry sulfur, the smell element—the atom behind rotten eggs, skunk spray, garlic, and hot springs. These two are the pair a water lab can print that a homeowner’s nose would have found long before the lab did: both are detectable by smell at trace levels far below anything a health assessment would ever discuss. One is the smell of the ocean. The other is the smell deliberately put into your gas line to keep you alive.
The Names
Because there are only two names in this pair, it is worth unpacking each one completely so you know exactly what the instrument picked up:
- Dimethyl sulfide — The smell of the sea. It is made by marine phytoplankton and released from the ocean in enormous quantities; it is a large part of what a sea breeze actually smells like, and it helps seed clouds over the oceans. On land, it shows up in the smell of cooked corn and cooked cabbage, in pulp-and-paper country, and in the background of natural waters near wetlands and decaying algae. Human beings also produce traces of it in ordinary digestion. It is a natural product of the living world and of the global sulfur cycle—the ocean breathing out.
- Ethanethiol — Also called ethyl mercaptan, and the most important smell in your house that you never chose. Natural gas and propane are odorless on their own, so utilities deliberately add ethanethiol to them: it is the “gas smell” itself, the rotten-cabbage stench that makes a leak impossible to ignore. It is among the most potent odorants known—the human nose detects it at extraordinarily low concentrations, well under a part per million, and it has been listed among the smelliest substances on Earth. It belongs to the thiol family, the same chemical family as skunk spray. It also occurs in petroleum and is handled industrially wherever gas is processed.
Why They Are in the Water at All
Dimethyl sulfide rides in from the natural world—algae, wetlands, decaying organic matter, and coastal air and rain all carry it, and microbes in sediments make more of it. Ethanethiol reaches water rarely and indirectly—around petroleum handling, gas processing, and industrial sites—and it does not persist: it oxidizes and breaks down quickly, and ordinary water disinfection destroys it.
A detection of either on a broad laboratory scan is a trace fingerprint of a source, not a dose. In practical terms, these are compounds a homeowner would smell long before a lab report arrived, and odor—not a printout—is how they announce themselves.
The Numbers
Neither name has a federal drinking-water limit—no Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) and no Maximum Contaminant Level Goal (MCLG)—and no EWG health guideline exists for either.
The numbers that actually govern these two are odor numbers, not health numbers: both are smelled at trace levels orders of magnitude below the concentrations workplace rules concern themselves with. In drinking water, there is no government number for either, because the nose closes the case first.
Health Framing
At the trace levels found in water, both are odor events, not poisoning events. Ethanethiol at industrial vapor concentrations is a workplace hazard handled with workplace rules—a different world from parts per billion in a glass of water. Dimethyl sulfide is a natural product of the ocean and of human digestion.
One safety rule stands above everything else here: because ethanethiol is the smell of a gas leak, a strong gas odor in a home is always treated as a possible leak first—leave and call the gas company or 911; do not go investigating your water.
What Removes Them
Because both compounds are volatile, aeration—spraying or cascading the water through air—strips them out, and granular activated carbon adsorbs what remains; oxidants, including ordinary chlorine disinfection, chemically destroy ethanethiol. A sediment filter does nothing for either, because they are dissolved gases, not particles.
The Bottom Line
Two names, both of them smells—the sea breeze and the leak alarm. The lab can print them, but your nose is the better instrument here, and it was built for exactly these two.
Facts first, then filter. — Steve


Leave a Reply